By Chethana Janith, Jadetimes News
Waves off the coast of the U.S. could generate 2.64 trillion kilowatt hours of electricity per year, that’s about 64% of last year’s total utility-scale electricity generation in the U.S. We won’t need that much, but one day experts do hope that wave energy will comprise about 10-20% of our electricity mix.
“Wave power is really the last missing piece to help us to transition to 100% renewables, ” said Marcus Lehmann, co-founder and CEO of CalWave Power Technologies, one of a number of promising startups focused on building wave energy converters.
But while scientists have long understood the power of waves, it’s proven difficult to build machines that can harness that energy, due to the violent movement and corrosive nature of the ocean, combined with the complex motion of waves themselves.
″Winds and currents, they go in one direction. It’s very easy to spin a turbine or a windmill when you’ve got linear movement. The waves really aren’t linear. They’re oscillating. And so we have to be able to turn this oscillatory energy into some sort of catchable form,” said Burke Hales, professor of cceanography at Oregon State University and chief scientist at PacWave, a Department of Energy-funded wave energy test site off the Oregon Coast. Currently under construction, PacWave is set to become the nation’s first full-scale, grid-connected test facility for these technologies when it comes online in the next few years.
“PacWave really represents for us an opportunity to address one of the most critical barriers to enabling wave energy, and that’s getting devices into the open ocean,” said Jennifer Garson, Director of the Water Power Technologies Office at the U.S. Department of Energy.
At the beginning of the year, the DOE announced $25 million in funding for eight wave energy projects to test their technology at PacWave. We spoke with a number of these companies, which all have different approaches to turning the oscillatory motion of the waves into electrical power.
Different approaches
Of the eight projects, Bay Area-based CalWave received the largest amount, $7.5 million.
A small-scale version of CalWave’s device, the xWave, recently returned after a successful 10-month deployment off the coast of San Diego.
″The device we’re testing at PacWave will be a larger version of this,” said Lehmann. The x800, our megawatt-class system, produces enough power to power about 3,000 households.”
CalWave’s device operates completely below the surface of the water, and as waves rise and fall, surge forward and backward, and the water moves in a circular motion, the device moves too. Dampers inside the device slow down that motion and convert it into torque, which drives a generator to produce electricity.
“And so the waves move the system up and down. And every time it moves down, we can generate power, and then the waves bring it back up. And so that oscillating motion, we can turn into electricity just like a wind turbine,” said Lehmann.
Another approach is being piloted by Seattle-based Oscilla Power, which was awarded $1.8 million from the DOE, and is getting ready to deploy its wave energy converter off the coast of Hawaii, at the U.S. Navy Wave Energy Test site.
Oscilla Power’s device is composed of two parts. One part floats on the surface and moves with the waves in all directions - up and down, side to side and rotationally. This float is connected to a large, ring-shaped structure which hangs below the surface, and is designed to stay relatively steady. The difference in motion between the float and the ring generates force on the connecting lines, which is used to rotate a gearbox to drive a generator.
″The system that we’re deploying in Hawaii is what we call the Triton-C. This is a community-scale system,” said Balky Nair, CEO of Oscilla Power. “It’s about a third of the size of our flagship product. It’s designed to be 100 kilowatt rated, and it’s designed for islands and small communities.”
Nair is excited by wave energy’s potential to generate electricity in remote regions, which currently rely on expensive and polluting diesel imports to meet their energy needs when other renewables aren’t available. Before wave energy is adopted at-scale, many believe we’ll see wave energy replacing diesel generators in off-the-grid communities.
A third company, C-Power, based in Charlottesville, Virginia, was awarded more than $4 million to test its grid-scale wave energy converter at PacWave. But first, the company wants to commercialize its smaller scale system, the SeaRAY, which is designed for lower-power applications.
″Think about sensors in the ocean, research, metocean data gathering, maybe it’s monitoring or inspection,” said C-Power CEO Reenst Lesemann on the initial applications of his device.
The SeaRAY consists of two floats and a central body, the nacelle, which contains the drivetrain. As waves pass by, the floats bob up and down, rotating about the nacelle and turning their own respective gearboxes which power the electric generators.
Eventually, C-Power plans to scale up its SeaRAY so that it’s capable of satellite communications and deep water deployments, before building a larger system, called the StingRAY, for terrestrial electricity generation.
Meanwhile, one Swedish company, Eco Wave Power, is taking another approach completely, eschewing offshore technologies in favor of simpler wave power devices that can be installed on breakwaters, piers, and jetties.
“All the expensive conversion machinery, instead of being inside the floaters like in the competing technologies, is on land just like a regular power station. So basically this enables a very low installation, operation, and maintenance cost,” explained CEO Inna Braverman.
The company’s floaters sit atop the water, and move up and down with the motion of the waves. This drives a hydraulic piston which compresses fluid that’s then stored in an accumulator. When the fluid is released, it turns a hydraulic motor which powers an electric generator.
Braverman says that the energy produced from her floaters is on par with the offshore competition. Already, the company has produced power for the grid in Gibraltar, and is finalizing another grid-connected station in Israel, both of which can power about 100 homes at peak efficiency. Eco Wave Power has also signed an agreement to install its tech at the Port of Los Angeles.
“I would like to see more companies focusing on easier projects that will give the population, the investors, the government the safety to say, okay, now it’s safe to legislate, now it’s safe to invest, now it’s safe to believe in wave energy,” said Braverman.
The Future
There are still many unknowns when it comes to wave energy tech, including whether costs can fall enough to become competitive with fossil fuels. Garson says that means getting to around 6 cents per kilowatt-hour, but that’s a long way way from the projected costs for current wave energy technologies, which Hales estimates are around $0.60 to $1.00 per kilowatt-hour.
Then there’s the impact of these devices on marine ecosystems.Wwhile there are ongoing efforts by the DOE and the companies themselves to monitor those effects, it will take time to get a full picture.
“This is going to have to be something that we learn as we put systems in the water. But we’re funding environmental monitoring, funding work to really understand the interaction of species with deployed systems,” said Garson.
Questions about environmental impacts could delay the permitting process as companies move beyond testing towards commercialization. One thing that could make permitting easier though is if there’s convergence around a particular design principle.
“I do believe that like what happened in the wind turbine space, there will be some level of convergence of technologies. It doesn’t mean that all of the components in the system and all the approaches implemented within the system are identical. But there will be some level of convergence we feel around an optimum,” said Nair.
Continued scale-up will largely depend upon consistent government investment in the U.S. and abroad. The recent passage of the Inflation Reduction Act, which includes $369 billion earmarked for clean energy and climate change mitigation has many optimistic, but most agree we still won’t see wave farms providing power to the mainland this decade.
“So we have a goal of setting about one gigawatt of power by 2035. And we really see that as the first opportunity for wave energy to come online to serve the nation’s grid,” said Garson.
